Expert Panel

This method is about the objective evaluation of ideas by a group of selected experts in a problem area. It allows getting additional insights and know-how by experts.

Organisation

  • Duration:
    Medium (about 30-60 minutes)
  • Complexity:
    Not defined
  • Group size:
    2 - 5 persons

Detaillied Description

Experts have acquired professional knowledge on a topic and are often scientifically trained professionals, in a broader way, everyone that has acquired special knowledge in a problem area through participation or involvement. The goal of an expert panel is to get a specific valuation of an idea. Moreover additional knowledge can be gathered and influence the foundation of a solution. For this method specialists or representatives of an interest group (panel) come together to assess the ideas presented. They present their view oft he concept and compare their opinions to create an additional benefit. A moderator can support the participants in their valuation. This method can be used at different points of the evaluation.

Illustration

Illustration

Preparation

  1. Get in contact with experts and arrange an expert panel. Experts can also be selected from the creative team.
  2. Develop valuation criteria.
  3. If applicable, presentation of the topic.

Execution

  1. Introduce the ideas tot he panel, whereas the ideas should be comparable and detailed, to allow a valuation by the experts.
  2. Recall the valuation criteria fort he participants.
  3. Present ideas systematically and assess them.
  4. Document the valuation.

Hints from experience

...

Tools list

  • (empty)

References

http://betterevaluation.org/evaluation-options/expert_panel